Mega-Trends Have Emerged That Drive Growth in HSAs

Employee Benefit Research Institute and Fidelity data show that more account holders are investing their health savings accounts assets.

Mega-trends are driving the growth of health savings accounts.

An Employee Benefit Research Institute webinar, “The Three Certainties of Life: Death, Taxes and Updates From The EBRI Health Savings Account Database,” examined several trends that are prompting the marketplace to continue to grow.

Get more!  Sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters.

EBRI’s health saving account database comprises 11.4 million HSAs, with assets totaling more than $32.9 billion, as of year-end 2020. In the last five years, the number of HSA accounts has grown more than 60% and the number of assets has grown by 250%, said Chris Byrd, executive vice president for healthcare operations at WEX, a fintech firm. “These accounts continue to grow very rapidly,” he said.

HSAs’ rapid growth since 2003, when HSAs were created, has been driven by employees wanting to cover rising health care costs in retirement. In addition, more employers have moved to high-deductible health plans that are paired with an HSA.

According to data from the Kaiser Family Foundation, 85% of people who are enrolled in an employer health plan have a general annual deductible, and the average deductible for single coverage in those plans is almost $1,700. “The context here is important: out of pocket exposure continues to rise,” Byrd said.

Plan sponsors offering an HSA have recognized that participants must save for medical expenses, which has provided fuel for trends, said William Giaconia, executive vice president for healthcare operations at Fidelity investments.

A trio of trends is driving growth, said Giaconia. First, account holders are investing their assets rather than keeping them in cash; second, plan sponsors are focusing more on employees’ financial wellness; third, there is an attendant accelerated trend in offering digital health resources and tools. “Our clients are viewing these products as not just products that employees can use to help pay for current health care expenses, but to save for future health care and other expenses in their retirement,” he said.

Fidelity reached an HSA milestone this year, as 50% of HSA assets were invested compared to 25% three years ago, he added. “We’re seeing that steady climb in invested accounts and assets,” Giaconia said.

EBRI’s database shows that in 2020, 9% of accounts held investments other than cash, compared to 7% in 2019.

The average balance for accounts with invested assets is $22,496, compared to $2,296 for accounts with no invested assets. “This as an indication that investors are using their HSA as more of a savings vehicle rather than spending vehicle,” said Jake Spiegel, research associate, health and wealth, at EBRI.

Invested accounts also have higher average contributions, higher net contributions, and “investors see their HSAs grow at a much faster pace than account holders who do not invest,” Spiegel added.

HSAs are also a way to help workers protect their retirement savings. “I don’t think it’s a surprise to anyone that about 30% or so, in our block of retirement business hardship withdrawals from retirement accounts, are for health care expense,” Giaconia said. But when plan sponsors offer both an HSA and a retirement plan, the figure is nearly cut in half, he added. “Even modest balances can really help to insulate that consumer from having to make a financial hardship withdrawal or to have a general financial hardship related to health care expenses, Giaconia said.

Wells Fargo Agrees to Settle Proprietary Funds Lawsuit

The settlement agreement includes a “significant monetary recovery,” the plaintiffs note in a memo in support of a motion for preliminary approval.

Parties in a lawsuit against Wells Fargo 401(k) plan fiduciaries have filed a motion for preliminary approval of a settlement.

According to a memo filed by the plaintiffs in support of the motion, under the terms of the proposed settlement, the defendants will pay a gross settlement amount of $32.5 million into a common fund for the benefit of the proposed settlement class. As the memo notes, “This is a significant monetary recovery for the class.” And, it says, the settlement “falls well within the range of court-approved settlements in similar [Employee Retirement Income Security Act] cases.”

Get more!  Sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters.

The original lawsuit, filed in March 2020, claims that upon the creation of the Wells Fargo/State Street Target collective investment trusts, or Target Date CITs, in 2016, the committee defendants added the CITs to the plan even though the funds had no prior performance history or track record which could demonstrate that they were prudent. Despite the lack of a track record, the committee defendants “mapped” nearly $5 billion of participants’ retirement savings from the plan’s previous target-date option into the Target Date CITs.

In addition, the lawsuit alleges the committee defendants used the plan’s assets to seed the Wells Fargo/Causeway International Value Fund, as evidenced by the fact that the plan’s assets constituted more than 50% of the total assets in the fund at year-end 2014. “Without such a substantial investment from the plan, Wells Fargo’s ability to market its new, untested fund would have been greatly diminished,” the complaint states.

The lawsuit further alleges that plan fiduciaries selected and retained for the plan 17 Wells Fargo proprietary funds, many of which underperformed the benchmark that the defendants selected as an appropriate broad-based market index for each fund.

Last May, Judge Donovan W. Frank of the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota refused to dismiss the suit, deciding that the “numerous and specific allegations are sufficient to support an inference of imprudence and disloyalty.” He also said the “allegations are far more than general assertions, and that accepted as true, show that defendants engaged in prohibited transactions.”

«