Competing Priorities Pose Challenges to Gen Z, Millennial Workers Saving for Retirement

Employers should encourage younger workers to build emergency savings before contributing toward the company match and paying off student debt, says author Anne Lester.

Because of plan design features like automatic enrollment, Gen Z and Millennial workers are saving more for retirement than Gen X and Baby Boomers were at the same age. 

However, for those in their twenties who are just entering the workforce, visualizing retirement and connecting with their future 65-year-old selves seems almost impossible.  

Get more!  Sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters.

Saving for retirement is also not a priority for a lot of younger workers. Fidelity’s 2024 State of Retirement Planning study found that 57% of Millennials and 56% of Gen Z believe they will have a harder time saving for retirement than their parents due to the higher cost of living.  

Anne Lester, formerly a portfolio manager and head of retirement solutions at J.P. Morgan Asset Management, recently published her book “Your Best Financial Life: Save Smart Now for the Future You Want,” which touches on the concept of connecting oneself with their “future stranger.” 

“There’s a lot of brain research that shows that when we think about ourselves in the future, and that future is more than five years… [we] literally use the part of our brain that thinks about strangers, to think about ourselves in the future,” Lester says. “When you save money, it entails sacrifice and pain because you’re delaying gratification for stuff you want now, and oh, by the way, you’re giving that money away to a complete stranger.” 

For younger investors to start “acquainting with that future investor,” Lester suggests that they ask themselves questions like where they see themselves in living in the future, how they see themselves spending their time and what they want their lifestyle to look like. She says these questions might be difficult for someone in their twenties to answer, but she encourages people to give themselves permission to fantasize about what their future life might be.  

For Gen Z and Millennial workers who have access to a workplace retirement plan, Lester says they are already “more on track” to retire than Gen X and Boomers were at their age, and she attributes this to the success of automatic enrollment and auto-escalation.  

When auto-enrollment first started taking off about ten years ago, Lester says most plan sponsors were uncomfortable with escalating participants beyond a 3% contribution.  

“A lot of plan sponsors now are auto-escalating people up to 10% or more, which is the best thing to help people save for retirement because it just automates the whole thing,” Lester says. “It takes [the participant] out of the equation. That’s what is going to help Gen Z and Millennials retire, assuming [they] are lucky enough to work for an employer who offers a plan.” 

Save in Order 

In her book, Lester lays out a hierarchy in which investors should tackle their expenses while building their savings.  

“In my mind, the single most important thing you should be doing is building up an emergency savings fund before everything else,” she says.  

Lester says it is particularly advantageous when employers offer an emergency savings fund next to the 401(k) plan, because it eliminates the barriers and complexity that come along with someone trying to set up an account themselves.  

After building up emergency savings, Lester says it is important for young investors to contribute toward their employer’s match because it’s “free money.”  

Lester recommends that participants dealing with student debt save up at least three months’ worth of emergency savings before they start tackling their debt.  

“If you don’t have an emergency savings fund and something happens, you’re going to get into an even bigger debt mess and then … you will have to borrow a ton of money that you can’t afford to repay,” Lester says.  

Retirement plans that offer a benefit like the student loan matching provision, which is outlined in the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022, are something that employees should take advantage of if available, Lester says.  

Lester emphasizes the importance of receiving the company match and saving early, as compounded returns are “really powerful.” She also says it is important for workers to understand a company’s retirement plan vesting schedule before they accept a job. 

For employers with high turnover rates, Lester says it makes sense to have a longer vesting schedule, as they are trying to retain people and offering a retirement plan can become very expensive. But from the employee’s perspective, it is in their best interest to capture that “free money” where they can.  

DOL Asks for Participant Information to Build Lost and Found Database

Plan administrators would voluntarily turn over data to DOL to help missing participants and plans find one another.

The Department of Labor has issued an information collection request asking plan administrators to voluntarily turn over information to the DOL that would enable it to create a participant lost and found for retirement plans governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act.

The lost and found is a database that would allow missing participants and plans to find each other, hopefully mitigating the issue of missing participants that struggle to locate their retirement savings accounts. Creation of such a database is required by December 29, 2024 under the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022.

Get more!  Sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters.

The DOL’s April 16 request includes a request for comments on what information would best enable it to create a proper database for this purpose and how the department can reduce the burden for participating administrators. The comment period for improving the data collection process closes on June 17.

Initially, according to the information collection request, the DOL had intended to get the lost and found information from data collected by the Internal Revenue Service through Form 8955-SSA, a filing in which qualified plans submit data on vested participants who have separated from participating employers. The IRS shares this document with the Social Security Administration, who then informs participants of their missing benefits when they apply for Social Security benefits.

This document may seem tailor-made for a lost and found database, but the IRS has said it does not have the legal authority to share the data with the DOL for purposes of contacting participants, due to confidentiality provisions in the Internal Revenue Code.

As a result, the DOL is asking plan administrators to provide contact information directly to the DOL voluntarily. The regulator is asking plans to provide the following for vested separated participants: names and Social Security numbers, contact information, mailing address, and whether they have received an involuntary distribution already.

The DOL also asked plans to indicate if a participant has been unresponsive to contact and to provide information on their designated beneficiaries, as well as the nature and amount of the benefit to which they are entitled.

Administrators would provide this information to the DOL as an attachment to their Form 5500 filings.

One of the three bills that later became SECURE 2.0, the Enhancing American Retirement Now Act, proposed in the Senate, would have made the Treasury Department responsible for creating a lost and found. Instead, it was assigned to the DOL by the House version, the Securing a Strong Retirement Act of 2022.

An explainer from the Groom Law Group suggests that keeping the database in-house at Treasury would have likely enabled IRS to provide the data from Form 8955-SSA for this purpose.

Kendra Isaacson, a principal at public policy consultancy Mindset and a former tax counsel for the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions, says that the lost and found was assigned to DOL because “fiduciary functions have always resided at the Department of Labor, and finding missing participants is a fiduciary function.”

Although it is true that the IRS would have been able to use Form 8955-SSA to build a database, Isaacson explains, it lacks the experience with tracking participants and other fiduciary functions that DOL has.

The DOL has not set a deadline for the voluntary turnover of information at this time, but has itself until December 29 to complete the database.

 

 

 

«