Financial Wellness Gap Between Men, Women Continues to Widen

While overall employee financial wellness showed improvement this year, the wellness and retirement confidence gap between men and women remains an issue, according to Bank of America. 

Despite struggling with debt and a higher cost of living, the number of employees feeling financially well in 2024 is trending up, according to Bank of America Institute’s 14th annual Workplace Benefits Report, “The Resurging Workforce.” 

This year’s survey revealed that 47% of employees rated their financial wellness as “good” or “excellent,” as opposed to 42% last year. However, women expressed significantly lower financial wellness scores than men, signaling that employers need to do more to address the issue of pay equity, among other challenges. 

Get more!  Sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters.

More than half (53%) of men reported good financial wellness, compared to 36% of women. As women in the U.S. working full-time still earn 84 cents for every dollar men earn, according to the Census Bureau, the issue of lower pay may be contributing to women’s low levels of financial confidence. 

However, the survey found that only 44% of employers currently address pay equity, and 28% are considering it in the next one to two years. The majority of employers (78%) with pay equity initiatives said they have seen an improvement in the ability to attract top talent. 

In addition, Bank of America reported that as of 2024, 52% of the workforce identify as caregivers, and BofA speculated that segment is potentially is even larger, as many employees do not feel comfortable self-identifying in a caregiving role. As more than 75% of caregivers are women, it is also notable that caregivers reported a lower financial wellness rating than non-caregivers. 

The report pointed out that there is often a disconnect between employers who say they offer caregiving benefits and employees’ awareness of them. For example, 81% of employers said they offer support to caregivers, but 61% of employees said they are not aware of this caregiving support. This indicates that many caregivers are not accessing the support that is available to them and that employers should enhance communications to encourage workers to take advantage of these benefits, such as leave of absence of sick days to give care to family members or employee assistance programs such as counseling or support groups. 

Job Turnover Trends 

Another key trend identified in the report was that, compared to last year, more employees said they switched jobs or considered doing so in the past year, while 27% are considering changing jobs in the next year. Notably, younger employees and women were more likely to want to make the switch.  

This year, top reasons why employees reported that they would consider leaving their jobs included compensation, followed by career growth, overall burnout and work/life balance. This differs from last year when burnout was cited as the number one reason why employees would consider leaving their jobs. 

More women than men also reported the ability to work remotely as a significant factor when considering leaving a company. 

Retirement Confidence 

At the same time, employees’ overall outlook for the future continues to improve, as more expressed optimism when looking ahead to the next two to three years. When setting financial savings goals, saving for retirement was at the top of the list, followed by paying off credit card debt, saving for unexpected expenses and paying off mortgages.  

Around two-thirds of employees said they are confident their 401(k) will build enough savings to allow them to live the retirement they envision, with men and members of older generations more confident than other employee segments. For instance, 70% of men said they are confident about their income in retirement, compared to 58% of women. 

Meanwhile, responses revealed a lack of understanding around how Social Security, Medicare and Health Savings Accounts could help supplement 401(k) savings in retirement. More employees lacked understanding of Social Security this year compared to employees in 2023, but many understood that Social Security cannot be their only source of income in retirement, with most employees expecting it to replace 40% or less of their pre-retirement earnings.  

In the last six to twelve months, the majority of employees reported not having taken any action regarding their savings for health care in retirement. But for those who did take action, more employees increased their retirement savings than decreased their savings.  

Bank of America recommended that employers help their employees understand not only how much they will need in retirement, but also where that income will come from. Providing access to retirement planning education, as well as personalized Social Security, Medicare and health care savings education by life stage, are also important for employers to keep in mind.  

In partnership with Escalent, Bank of America surveyed a national sample of 955 employees who are working full-time and participate in 401(k) plans, and 804 employers who offer both a 401(k) plan and have sole or shared responsibility for decisions made in the plan.  

Acquisition from Ascensus Will Expand Principal’s ESOP Business

Deal will bring Principal's market representation to more than 2,000 ESOP plans and about 765,000 participants.

Principal Financial Group has announced an agreement to acquire the employee stock ownership plan business from Ascensus, further solidifying Principal’s leading position in the marketplace.

When the deal closes, which is expected by the end of the second quarter, Principal will add 800 ESOP plans and more than 165,000 participants. That will bring the retirement solutions provider’s total market representation to more than 2,000 ESOP plans and about 765,000 participants, according to the announcement. The firms did not disclose the terms of the deal.

The deal between Principal and Ascensus will merge two of the country’s largest ESOP providers by assets, according to the 2023 PLANSPONSOR DC Benchmarking Survey. Blue Ridge ESOP Associates currently administers 1,600 plans, according to the firm, in part from growth after a 2022 acquisition of Crowe LLP’s ESOP business.

Principal noted a growing market for ESOPs by companies in recent years, in part due to the tight labor market, for the acquisition. In research conducted by the National Center for Employee Ownership, a nonprofit membership association that supports the space, the group noted that employees with ESOP plans tend to believe they have an advantage in recruiting and retaining talent—with about 79% of such employers saying they do much better or somewhat better than competitors in recruiting and retainment.

“Hundreds of new ESOPs are formed every year, and companies that already have ESOPs continue to outperform their markets— one reason for that growth is the bench depth of the service providers in the field,” says Loren Rodgers, executive director of NCEO. “The acquisition of Ascensus’s ESOP business by the Principal Financial Group is a sign of the field’s health—I see it as an investment in the resources available to ESOP companies, and I’m delighted that there are still a dozen administration firms that have large ESOP client bases and deep expertise.”

Principal also cited additional products and tools as impetus for the purchase. That will include adding Ascensus’ ESOP economics consulting group and its Telescope software, which provides clients with a forecast of ESOP repurchase obligations and alternative options, according to Ascensus’ website.

“The acquisition positions us to offer greater value, enhanced services, and stronger products to our ESOP clients, and the integration of strong talent from Ascensus will be essential to support the growth of our ESOP business,” Andrew Matos, head of stock plan services for Retirement and Income Solutions at Principal, said in a statement.

For Ascensus, the sale happens just after it has been making acquisitions in other areas under new President Nick Good.

In April, the tax-advantaged solutions provider acquired Vanguard’s individual 401(k), Multiple Participant SEP and SIMPLE IRA Plans divisions. That followed the March acquisition of Mutual of Omaha’s 401(k) recordkeeping business, which Ascensus had been operating as a vendor, but then took over to manage the more than 2,300 retirement plans.

Principal’s acquisition also comes as the DOL reportedly nears a proposal on adequate consideration rules for ESOPs in coming months. The ESOP provider industry has been awaiting the proposal to help shape up a more public market for the appraisal of the shares in ESOP plans in part to protect from regulatory and litigation risk due to lack of benchmarking.

“It appears ESOPs are having a moment,” says NCEO’s Rodgers. “I keep hearing encouraging words not only from federal agencies and from members of Congress, but especially from state governments actively seeking to encourage employee ownership. They’ve seen the benefits to their constituents when employees own a share in the company, and they’re also seeing that rooting business ownership in communities makes those communities more resilient.”

«