November 4, 2005 (PLANSPONSOR.com) - The Senate has
approved a budget measure that will increase annual premiums
paid by employers to the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation
(PBGC) to $46.75 per participant from $19 per participant,
Business Insurance reports.
In addition, the measure would impose a $1,250
per-participant fee on employers who terminate their plans
due to bankruptcy.
The premium hike and bankruptcy fee will not go into
effect if the Senate passes its pension reform this
year.
The Senate’s reform bill is currently on
hold due to arguments about the special treatments of
airlines in the bill’s provisions (See
Senate Pension Proposal Still on
“Hold”
).
Business Insurance said the House is also expected
next week to vote on a measure that would raise the PBGC
premium to $30 but would give the PBGC automatic
authority to boost the premium rate by 20% a year if the
agency considered it necessary. Congress would have
the authority to block the increase (See
Boehner Committee Approves PBGC Funding Measure
).
Business groups are generally against PBGC premium
hikes, saying they will continue to keep employers from
offering defined benefit pension plans.
But there are times when, no matter how boring the
meeting is, you have to be there – and you have to at least
appear to be paying attention.
This week we asked readers their secret(s) for staying
attentive – or at least awake – for a boring meeting.
“I cannot WAIT until I can find out some secrets
tomorrow. I’ll put them to use on Monday!”
noted one of this week’s respondents.
As you might imagine, tabulating this week’s responses
was a bit of a challenge.
But, allowing for some editorial discretion in the
compilation, the most common approach utilized by this
week’s respondents (nearly
27%
) might be categorized as “faking it,” pretending to be
interested and engaged, generally by tilting one’s head so
that the eyes can close occasionally, as well as the
careful propping of head and elbows.
“Rest your elbows on the chair arms and have your hands
comfortably up in the air,”
counseled one.
“When you begin to sleep, your arms will fall, waking
you up.”
Another “student” of the science of faking it said,
“If the meeting was big enough, I’d put my pen in my
hand and put it on a piece of paper, then rest my forehead
in the other hand and look down at the page.
That way if I started to fall asleep, which was almost
guaranteed, at least my head wouldn’t be bobbing
around.”
Another “expert” noted,
“I have learned over time how to look like I’m
listening while daydreaming about other things.
I make sure to look at the speaker periodically and watch
my nonverbals.
Doesn’t mean I’ve heard a thing.”
Another said,
“I watch the crowd and use eyeball- to-eyeball contact
to redirect the attention of other bored meeting members to
the one who is nodding or sleeping while thinking of an
on-topic but unanswerable question for the person who
called this unnecessary meeting.”
One noted,
“I force myself to sit up very straight, shoulders back
and not resting my back against the chair or my elbows on
the conference table.
I stay awake and alert, and people think I have good
posture.”
Some readers have honed these “skills” over many years,
such as the reader who said,
“My secret to ‘attentiveness’ is something learned in
middle school: bring paper, a writing utensil, and sit next
to someone sociable.
We appear to be taking notes; in reality, we’re discussing
lunch, weekend activity, and probably how boring the
meeting is.”
In fact, taking notes was the third most popular
category, cited by more than
12%
.
“No matter how boring, it’s hard to fall asleep
while you’re writing,”
commented one.
“If I can get away with it, I bring other work that I need
to do, giving the impression that I am taking notes,”
said another.
In a comment that will no doubt chill public speakers
everywhere, one note taker said,
“Even if the notes have nothing to do with the meeting,
I must take notes to keep from passing out.
For instance, I might make a grocery list.
Many times I believe I have given the speaker a rush of
confidence and validation when he has looked at the
excitement on my face as I nod and write on my note pad,
“Toilet paper – must pick up some TP before going home
tonight!”
However, more popular than note taking was ingesting
stimulants – generally coffee – cited by
17%
.
For those who think this is a fairly sedate alternative,
consider the reader who said,
“To remain alert during boring meetings I balance a cup
of hot coffee on my thigh.
Seriously.”
To which I would say there is no other way to do it.
Another said,
“Drink a lot.
Water, coffee, whatever is available.
If I feel like I have to use the ladies’ room, it’s
impossible for me to fall asleep.
This only works, however, for meetings that are under two
hours, or meetings that have breaks scheduled at least
every two hours.
Otherwise, this strategy is just a biohazard.”
That same reader also offered an alternative to the
alternative:
“Start singing a really annoying song to yourself.
One of those songs that you just can’t get out of your
head.
Like ‘Can’t Touch This’ or ‘Ice Ice Baby.’
In a pinch, the Peanuts theme song works well, too, but you
sometimes wind up with a goofy grin on your face or bopping
your head involuntarily.”
Roughly
10%
each succumbed to making to do lists, doodling, or the
“allure” of technology.
In the latter category, one noted,
“To stay awake in boring meetings, I often play Yahtzee
on my PDA (with the sound off)!”
Another more pointedly observed,
“Isn’t that why the ‘crackberry’ was invented?”
Nearly
8%
did “other” work in the meeting (some did it on their
laptops during the meeting), and
5%
“fantasized.”
“If I’m hearing something that I don’t want to hear and
that is upsetting, I sometimes press my index finger
insistently on whatever hard, flat surface is in front of
me – pushing the imaginary button that activates the hidden
trap door that is under whomever is making the unpleasant
announcement. A very cathartic flight of fancy!”
noted one.
Believe it or not, nearly
3%
of this week’s respondents dealt with a boring meeting – by
trying really hard to pay attention.
“One of the most important things I learned in college
is that if I sit front and center (or in the direct site
line of the speaker), and make eye contact with the
speaker, not only do I stay awake, I pay attention!”
said one.
There were a number of creative alternatives suggested.
Here’s a sampling:
“When desperate, I’ll try and
estimate what the meeting’s ‘cost’ is based on each
attendees’ guesstimated salary pro-rated for the amount of
time the meeting lasts.
It’s sort of an EVA calculation to confirm my disdain for
being there in the first place!”
“I have found that virtually
all presenters have a ‘crutch word’ that they tend to use
more than they should.
I occasionally have to listen to one speaker who seems to
say ‘vis-Ã -vis’ in every other sentence.
Really, how many times can that phrase be the single best
choice of words in a 15-minute period?
So, counting people’s crutch words is perhaps my
favorite way to stay awake.”
“The euphoric expectation
that my incredible concentration and understanding will
qualify me for an exponentially higher pay raise than the
guy next to me who is asleep.”
Those interested in a making-a-boring-meeting-productive
primer will appreciate the following:
1. Always sit strategically
at the table/in the meeting room so others can’t see
what you are writing or reading.
2. Never take just a
tablet, take a portfolio that holds a tablet on one side
and a pocket for reading material on the other.
3. I take other memos or
just reading material I need to get through.
I’ve even made photocopies of newspaper/magazine
articles to read so I can mix them among presentation
material.
4. Boring meetings are a
great time to make “to do” lists.
I’ve made work to-do lists, grocery lists, weekend
to-do lists, Christmas lists, goals for my life lists,
you name it.
It just looks like you are taking notes during the
meeting.
If you are working with numbers during your meeting, this
is a great time for working on your own personal budget,
especially if you have a calculator with you.
5. Always make sure, if
possible, to make one comment or ask one question so you
don’t look totally tuned out. Otherwise, at some
point during the meeting, make some eye contact with the
presenters and other meeting attendees (if you are
sitting at a table) and do some head nods that you are
agreeing with what they are saying.
But this week’s
Editor’s Choice
– from what was undoubtedly one of the most competitive
weeks ever – goes to the reader whose best way to deal with
boring meetings was
“Clearly, the best solution is ‘don’t go!'”
Thanks to everyone who participated in our
survey!
Recognizing the reality of this helps one stay awake.
Wasting time listening means at least you did not waste
time preparing to cause others to waste time listening.
There needs to be a light at the end of the tunnel that is
not a train -- notices of meeting start times should be
accompanied by a stop time so everyone knows what they
should expect to have to endure.
Staying awake at boring meetings.....isn't that why
the "crackberry" was invented?
Taking lots of notes.
No matter how boring, it's hard to fall asleep while
you're writing.
Staying awake is very, very tough. I write to-do lists
or, if desperate, doodle.
Let's see ... if the meeting was big enough, I'd
put my pen in my hand and put it on a piece of paper, then
rest my forehead in the other hand and look down at the
page.
That way if I started to fall asleep, which was almost
guaranteed, at least my head wouldn't be bobbing
around.
If the meeting is a small group, I make a lot of trips to
"get coffee" and "go to the ladies"
room.
Both of which were excuses to walk around in the
hallway.
I have found that virtually all presenters have a
"crutch word" that they tend to use more than
they should.
I occasionally have to listen to one speaker who seems to
say "vis a vis" in every other sentence.
Really, how many times can that phrase be the single best
choice of words in a 15 minute period?
So, counting people's crutch words is perhaps my
favorite way to stay awake.
It's also not all that different (although much less
obvious) than "meeting bingo," where you create a
bingo board with all of the great business buzz words of
the day -- first one to get "synergy," "out
of the box," "organic growth,"
"rightsizing," and "robust" wins!
The key to surviving meetings is taking ridiculously
thorough notes. Then, when I return to my desk, I can
figure out what I should have learned from the last hour
while my mind was vacationing.
Great question, if I can get away with it, I bring other
work that I need to do, giving the impression that I am
taking notes.
Sometimes, I just completely tune out and think of other
things, try not to look at my watch, shift positions often,
anything to stay away.
The bigger issue here is that boring people should not be
allowed to give boring presentations.
Even better...........face reality, not everyone should be
allowed to give presentations; there is an art to this.
Presentations should also be limited to at maximum 40
minutes, reduce the number of slides (if projecting a
PowerPoint) and reduce the amount of information on the
slide.
There is nothing worse than listening to a presenter read
all the information on the slide, that being the case, why
have the meeting, just send the presentation ahead of time
and call in a Q&A session after.
I take notes - which I like to think engages me mentally
and physically.
I try not to eat a lot during the lunch break and drink
cold caffeinated sodas instead of coffee or tea. Then just
drink ice water. We also try to take 5-10 minute breaks
between speakers or presenters, to let board members get
up, stretch, take a quick walk, which all seems to help.
It must really be frustrating to managers that travel
across the country for their 30-40 minute presentation,
only to have several people at the board table dozing while
they're speaking.
Taking notes, which is good idea anyway because
sometimes you actually hear something that matters.
What's your "secret" for staying attentive
(or at least awake) for a boring meeting?
Fantasizing
I don't have a "secret".
Why do I need one?
If it's a boring meeting, but I must attend, my time is
better served sleeping.
I do try to make sure I am seated so my head doesn't
fall back...snoring would be impolite to those around me,
who are also probably trying to sleep.
I doodle on my note pad and make it appear that I'm
taking notes!
I take good, detailed notes.
Keeps me occupied so I'm not tempted to daydream or
drift off...
I force myself to sit up very straight, shoulders back
and not resting my back against the chair or my elbows on
the conference table.
I stay awake and alert and people think I have good
posture.
Now that's a survey question I can answer.
I am the queen of multitasking.
I take my laptop and when the topic is being beaten to
death, I work on other projects or answer emails.
Thank g_d for the network connections in our conference
rooms!!!
I try to take a lot of notes, even if I won't really
need them.
My theory is, I can't fall asleep while writing.
Sometimes the "notes" are my shopping list or
things I need to get done.
On the other hand, I do remember one particularly long,
sleep inducing, lecture in college, when I truly did feel I
*needed* to take the notes, where that plan didn't
work.
When I went back to read my notes later, they kept
trailing off into squiggles, and at one point it looked
like I had written "parasites on toast".
That one still makes me laugh.
Coffee!
I organize my work "to do" list so wasted
meeting time becomes productive.
Everyone thinks I'm taking meeting notes.
It always works!
The secret to whether a meeting is boring or not is to
look around the room and count how many other heads are
bobbing and how many eyes look heavy. If I can see it in
others, then I know the leader of the meeting has got to
notice it and it makes me work harder to not be one of them
and give the leader more eye contact to let them know they
have at least one captive audience member.
I can't say I've really stayed attentive, but I
have learned over time how to look like I'm listening
while daydreaming about other things.
I make sure to look at the speaker periodically and watch
my nonverbals.
Doesn't mean I've heard a thing.
If I really need to know what is being said, I take notes
so I don't fall asleep.
I tend to doodle during meetings, whether I'm
interested or not.
I only make an effort not to when I'm meeting with
people outside the company.
In that case, I drink a lot of water or try to catch the
eyes of whoever is speaking and see how long I can keep
them looking at me.
I've been in meetings where I can tell some
attendees, who don't know me, think I'm not paying
attention.
I LOVE to all of a sudden insert some comment or really
penetrating question in the middle of doodling that proves
I know exactly what's going on and then continuing my
doodling.
It's the small pleasures in life, ya know?
The euphoric expectation that my incredible
concentration and understanding will qualify me for an
exponentially higher pay raise than the guy next to me who
is asleep.
I watch the crowd and use eyeball to eyeball contact to
redirect the attention of other bored meeting members to
the one who is nodding or sleeping while thinking of an
on-topic but unanswerable question for the person who
called this unnecessary meeting.
My secret to "attentiveness" is something
learned in middle school: bring paper, a writing utensil,
and sit next to someone sociable.
We appear to be taking notes; in reality, we're
discussing lunch, weekend activity, and probably how boring
the meeting is.
...my secret to staying awake during a meeting is
replaying the movie Office Space in my head...especially
the part where he is eating cheetos and playing Tetris on
his computer.
You have to be careful, though, and pay attention a little
bit in case you get called on, so you don't look like
an idiot!!
To remain alert during boring meetings I balance a cup
of hot coffee on my thigh.
Seriously.
Coffee before. Leg movement during the meeting,
it is like stretching and yawning, but no one can see you
do it.
My secret is to keep my hands and fingers occupied with
something I can fiddle with. Or, bring a pound of caffeine
with me to the meeting.
Caffeine - and lots of it!
I take copious notes.
The practice forces me to listen to the speaker and keeps
me awake.
This is an easy one - One of the most important things I
learned in college is that if I sit front and center (or in
the direct site line of the speaker), and make eye contact
with the speaker not only do I stay awake, I pay
attention!
For those of us with required continuing education we
have all had a few conferences that we thought would be
useful only to find out that we have signed up for the
greatest cure for insomnia.
I have tried numerous things.
Once I was in at a conference for 2 days that was horrible.
I sat at the back of the room and cross stitched. I have
also written letters.
(I have seen people who using their pda's reading their
email and working on reports.)
But, I try to be nicer now and usually take reading
materials that I never seem to have time for at work and
read discretely. Or I make lists of things I need to do at
home and at work.
And I do try to listen and take at least one thing from the
meeting or conference, but just in case I always keep a
couple of pages of available so I can update my to do lists
or plan.
During boring meetings, I do the following to stay
attentive (or awake!):
Try and write down the high points of the presenters
remarks.
Occasionally shift my posture to ward off the
sandman.
When desperate, I'll try and estimate what the meeting's
"cost" is based on each attendees guesstimated salary
pro-rated for the amount of time the meeting lasts.
It's sort of an EVA calculation to confirm my disdain for
being there in the first place!
My secrets for staying awake during a boring
meeting:
1. Drink a lot.
Water, coffee, whatever is available.
If I feel like I have to use the ladies room, it's
impossible for me to fall asleep.
This only works, however, for meetings that are under 2
hours, or meetings that have breaks scheduled at least
every two hours.
Otherwise, this strategy is just a biohazard.
2. Start singing a really annoying song to
yourself.
One of those songs that you just can't get out
of your head.
Like "Can't Touch This" or "Ice Ice
Baby."
In a pinch, the Peanuts theme song works well, too, but you
sometimes wind up with a goofy grin on your face or bopping
your head involuntarily.
What's your "secret" for staying attentive
(or at least awake) for a boring meeting?.
Clearly, the best solution is "don't
go!"
I cannot WAIT until I can find out some secrets
tomorrow. I'll put them to use on Monday!
My tactic is pretty obvious ... head down, eyes closed,
rubbing my forehead while trying to pay attention - then I
have to resort to caffeine.
Some co-workers doodle, some play solitaire on their
laptop, some write notes for later in the day. We're
not too creative - we all know we are bored!
Take notes.
Even if the notes have nothing to with the meeting, I must
take notes to keep from passing out.
For instance, I might make a grocery list.
Many times I believe I have given the speaker a rush of
confidence and validation when he has looked at the
excitement on my face as I nod and write on my note pad,
"Toilet paper - must pick up some TP before going home
tonight!"
Here are my secrets for staying attentive in boring
meetings (and I have attended many):
1. Always sit strategically at the table/in the meeting
room so others can't see what you are writing or
reading.
2. Never take just a tablet, take a portfolio that holds
a tablet on one side and a pocket for reading material on
the other.
3. I take other memos or just reading material I need to
get through.
I've even made photocopies of newspaper/magazine
articles to read so I can mix them among presentation
material.
4. Boring meetings are a great time to make "to
do" lists.
I've made work to-do lists, grocery lists, weekend
to-do lists, Christmas lists, goals for my life lists, you
name it.
It just looks like you are taking notes during the meeting.
If you are working with numbers during your meeting, this
is a great time for working on your own personal budget,
especially if you have a calculator with you.
5. Always make sure, if possible, to make one comment or
ask one question so you don't look totally tuned out.
Otherwise, at some point during the meeting, make some eye
contact with the presenters and other meeting attendees (if
you are sitting at a table) and do some head nods that you
are agreeing with what they are saying.
Some of the boring meetings I actually look forward to,
because it is time in my schedule I can let my mind wander
and not be interrupted by phone calls, emails, and get some
thinking done.
I know it sounds like I've put a lot of thought into
this, and I really am a fully-engaged, good employee,
however, I feel like too much time is wasted on meetings
that are totally unnecessary.
I needed to find ways to make this wasted meeting time
productive.
I think this would make a good Dilbert comic.
To stay awake in boring meetings, I often play Yahtzee
on my PDA (with the sound off)!
If I'm hearing something that I don't want to hear
and that is upsetting, I sometimes press my index finger
insistently on whatever hard, flat surface is in front of
me - pushing the imaginary button that activates the hidden
trap door that is under whomever is making the unpleasant
announcement. A very cathartic flight of fancy!
During less than interesting meetings and presentations,
I'm horribly guilty of starting lists of things I need
to accomplish once the meeting is over, projects I would
like to tackle and contemplating personal and professional
goals.
If it gets really bad I'll start making the grocery
list.
Rest your elbows on the chair arms and have your hands
comfortably up in the air.
When you begin to sleep, your arms will fall waking you
up.
It helps to take a few notes, even if I throw them away
after the meeting ends, and focus on writing down any I
will need to take as a result of the meeting.
I hate meetings.
I stay awake by drinking coffee, doodling & thinking of
what kind of Extreme Makeover I would give the speaker.
I worked for someone who was an avid reader of
management-oriented books.
Every year or so, he would find a book that he felt offered
a panacea for all of the organization's ills…
And thus began a series of interminable "strategy
sessions" aimed at adapting our organization to the
strategies outlined in the book.
After three or four cycles of book-based-reinvention, our
management team had (understandably) become very cynical
towards these efforts, and nobody invested a lot of mental
energy in them.
Few of the meetings involved any meaningful discussion;
they were usually three-hour long monologues (occasionally
supplemented by strange drawings and poorly conceived
flowcharts) where the biggest challenge was appearing to
remain mentally present (actually being mentally present
wasn't required since discussions were nil).
I learned to "fake it" by preparing lists—shopping lists,
weekend to-do lists, prospective names for yet-to-be-had
children.
List-making was accompanied by periodically furrowing my
brow and nodding my head, thus convincing my boss that I
was diligently striving to grasp a particularly deep
concept.
And when all else failed, there was always the old
stand-by: Get up and go to the restroom, regardless of
whether there was any real need to go to the restroom.
There were only two problems with this approach: People
either thought I had some sort of severe coffee-intolerance
or they would stumble across me in the kitchen reading
magazines and loading up on coffee and donuts.
This happens far too often - I usually have to pinch
myself to try and stay awake.