TIAA Finds Retirement Plan Leakage Offsets Automatic Enrollment Benefits

While automatic enrollment generates positive effects, a report argues how these results are counterweighed by pre-retirement withdrawals.

With benefits from kick starting retirement savings to fostering participant engagement, automatic enrollment has proven itself to be an important plan feature. Yet, this does not acquit it from including its own set of drawbacks.  

Never miss a story — sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan benefits news.

A recent TIAA Institute survey examined the utilization of outstanding loans and withdrawals in accordance to automatic enrollment, otherwise known as “leakage” and found that “among households under the age of 55, each dollar contributed to a 401(k) plan or similar tax-advantaged retirement account is offset by approximately 40 cents in pre-retirement taxable withdrawals.” While automatic enrollment generates positive effects, the report argues how these results are counterweighed by pre-retirement withdrawals.

Survey results were extracted from a Fortune 500 company, when the company had initiated a 2% default contribution rate for employees hired after July 2005 until 2013. The study compared employees hired in the first year after the automatic enrollment implementation, to those employed during in the 12 months prior.  

Among other findings, the study reported automatic enrollment raised “total potential retirement system balance by 7% of starting pay eight years after hire.” However, unrolled loans and withdrawals increased by 3% of starting pay, which in turn, offsets “approximately 40% of the potential increase in savings from automatic enrollment,” according to the study.

Additionally, the study says automatic enrollment at the company elevated retirement system balances by 4% to 5% of “first year pay eight years after hire.” However, for those tenured employees who remained with the company, leakage in the form of plan loans were found to offset 9% to 27% of potential savings. For low-level tenured employees who no longer stayed with the company, leakage (as non-rollover withdrawals) accounted for over half of budding savings. The study points out that while these numbers decline for separated employees over time, the rate after eight years still surpassed 40%.

More information about the study can be found here.

TRIVIAL PURSUITS: What Is Salami?

There’s actually a strong connection between salami and a favorite pizza topping—pepperoni.

What is salami?

 

Get more!  Sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters.

Salami, or Salame in Italian, is a combination of salted meats, instead of a particular type of meat. And because salami is so broad, it can be prepared in many different ways, despite each type going more or less go through the same processing phases. The difference is mainly in terms of spice mix, but also the ground meat which can vary in consistency from salami to salami.

 

It is a type of cured sausage consisting of fermented and air-dried meat, typically beef or pork. Genoa salami is traditionally made of pork and veal meat, and typically seasoned with garlic, pepper, and red wine.

 

Interestingly, pepperoni is a fine-grained, smokey, air-dried salami. That is somewhat of a redundant description considering salami is dried sausage, but the air drying is an essential part of getting the texture of pepperoni. Air drying is the process of adding salt and nitrate to a meat, storing in the fridge, then drying in the air.

«